A cosmetics applicator and method of using the applicator are provided. The applicator has a body formed from a resilient material and is covered with a flexible, non-porous exterior coating that conforms to the shape of the body and is adhered to the material forming the body. The resilient body provides an applicator that is suitable for applying cosmetics to a user's skin, and the non-porous coating prevents cosmetics from being absorbed by the material forming the body.