A new and distinct cultivar of Chrysanthemum plant named ‘Fancy Yoursula’, characterized by its compact, upright, outwardly spreading and mounded plant habit; very freely branching habit; dense and full plant habit; uniform and freely flowering habit; small decorative-type inflorescences with ligulate-shaped ray florets; orange bronze-colored ray florets; and natural season flowering date of about September 14th in the Northern Hemisphere.